Vineyard Style Magazine, Capturing the Essence of Martha's Vineyard Living SUBSCRIBESUBSCRIBE


Full Circle
Architect Patrick Ahearn Imagines Three Centuries of History

By John Budris Photography by Taylor Ahearn

The demure cottage was a gift to his new bride, Jane Smith. The three-quarter, timber-framed home was but the third residence in what would become the “town.”

Chase was not a sea captain, so he could not afford the kind of prestige home seen in Edgartown a century later, when the profits of whaling were evident with widow’s walks on the roof peaks and elaborately carved woodworking in the parlors. In fact, Thomas Chase’s home doubled as an inn to help make ends meet during his trips to sea, the Air B&B of its era. After his death in a shipwreck during a gale off the Virginia coast in 1721, Chase’s widow maintained the inn with her new husband, Thomas Cathcart.

As the decades unfolded, and the Revolutionary and Civil Wars came and went on the Vineyard, and while the home’s ownership passed between a who’s-who of Vineyard family names, the house and grounds evolved and adapted along with the growing commercial and merchant activity on Main Street. New owners built a carriage house and other outbuildings as need required and resources were available. At times the home did double-duty as a store.

On a windy Saturday night on August 11, 1883, everything changed on Main Street. A tannery adjacent to the home - then on the site of today’s Stone Bank development - caught fire, and the northerly gale that spread the inferno southward, in fact, spared the “Chase House” from major harm. The home was hardly scorched and was but a handful in Vineyard Haven which the fire did not burn to ashes. The tragedy of the Great Fire pushed the Thomas Chase house’s rank to the oldest surviving home in town.

In the wake of the catastrophe and rebuilding of Vineyard Haven, the home continued its place as part of Main Street’s commercial and residential marriage. Fast forward to contemporary times, and when architect Patrick Ahearn FAIA was given the task to bring the home up to 21st century standards, the challenge would have frightened many away.  

“The fact is that Main Street became more commercial during the years, in the late 1800s after the fire and more in the 1900s,” says Ahearn. “This has a special meaning in my way of thinking to really get it right and do it right. Because it tells the tale of a different Main Street from a historical point of view.”  

In every home Ahearn addresses, the history of the dwelling and context of its location direct his vision. Even when building brand new, the implied history of what “could have been” is his architect’s compass.  

“But here we had real history. We went through the archival photographs from the late 1800s, when photography came on the scene, and you can see clearly what was the original house from 1712,” says Ahearn. “Over time, some really weird additions were stuck on it, one particularly at the backside that just overpowered the house.” 

Central to Ahearn’s planning was keeping the original footprints of both the main house and all of the additions right where they were. “On the primary facade of the original house, we didn’t really change anything other than new materials and windows and things like that,” says Ahearn.

The mutual goal of both Ahearn and his clients sought to preserve and support the historic shell while reimagining the interior in a classic Vineyard tradition. Recalling that Thomas Chase built the main house some 300 years ago with available materials and a workingman’s budget, this would be no easy challenge. The first task was to lift and secure the home so the crumbling fieldstone foundation could be excavated and removed. Once a new, poured concrete foundation was in place, the restoration and rehabilitation could commence in earnest. The structural floors remained while the joists were all sistered to further stabilize and strengthen the home’s bones.

And then the fun began. The property’s history informed the new detailing on the home’s interior. The now exposed reclaimed beams, wide plank floors, and significant architectural wall paneling all reinforce how the home evolved from the 18th century to the 21st.

“Even with the flooring and other details, with the things you touch and feel and see, we wanted to recall the past, even though we used some poetic license,” says Ahearn. “We wanted it to feel that there was a history, an implied history in the interior that told the story of this house in a more modern way, but always reminiscent of what came before.”

In a reference to what might have been in his adherence to implied history, Ahearn chose to use bead-board on the walls and ceilings. Typically employed by more wealthy homeowners in the early Colonial period to provide insulation and reduce draft, in this application, Ahearn’s choice added a coastal character to the informal spaces.

During the home’s long life, the original post and beam structures - which would have been initially exposed - gradually were covered up in the ensuing three centuries, as tastes and uses of its owners changed. So that early timber frame character was not well-expressed by the time Ahearn took on the project. “So we re-used some old timbers in the living room to highlight the interior, and to telegraph that post and beam history,” says Ahearn.

What puts the Thomas Chase House in a league of its own is its location, perched above and overlooking Vineyard Haven harbor.

“We obviously wanted to take advantage of being on the water and maximizing the views to the harbor and beyond,” says Ahearn. “And we took some license about making the house ‘live’ the way people want to live today - in terms of opening up these views to the rear and the porch.” At the home’s rear, water side, generous banks of windows now bring harbor views into every room. A sheltered porch with a fireplace is a natural transition between outdoors and inside, bringing the delight of the exterior views together with interior-like comfort.

On the second floor, decks span the full length of the house, with French doors connecting the interior rooms with the open-air environment.

While some architects might see the site’s steeply sloping grade toward the harbor as a detriment, Ahearn saw the hill as a welcomed challenge, like poet charged with writing a sonnet. “So we built this little folly building that’s tucked into the hill. It looks just like a little shed, but it also doubles as a garage heading to the lane down below,” says Ahearn. “The shed really doesn’t block the view, but gives the family the ability to store a car in the off-season and secure bicycles, kayaks and all the beach goodies in the summer.”

The devil is always in the details, and Ahearn spared none. Window boxes now overflow with flowers on the street facade that once was so overgrown with shrubbery that the house was camouflaged behind a wall of unruly vegetation.

In keeping with the theme of a sea-side cottage, he added new brick and stone retaining walls, and veneered the new concrete foundation by re-purposing some of the very stones Thomas Chase hefted himself when he first dug his cellar some 311 years ago.

Things have come full circle, and the new owners are indeed pleased. And one would suspect so would Thomas Chase.

To find out more about Patrick Ahearn Architect visit:

Boston Office: 160 Commonwealth Ave., Boston, MA, (617) 266-1710

Vineyard Office: Nevin Square, 17 Winter Street, Edgartown, MA, (508) 939-9312